I've finally completed another trip with the Goondie, and it was a much longer one this time, sleeping in the Goondie for 14 consecutive nights, so I'm getting a much better feel for it.
I do miss the integral pitch. The tent gets a bit wet on the inner while setting up in the rain, but it's not that much of a problem - it's no wetter than most tents get from condensation anyhow, and the water is still on the outside of the inner tent, and generally doesn't get through that layer of fabric.
The fly having its own waterproof stuff sack proved to be beneficial. When wet, I could pack it separately, but even when I did not, the inner remained dry, when the fly had been packed with it (the waterproof floor of the inner, which was all the packed-away fly touched would have helped a lot here too).
Speaking of the floor, the Goondie was the only one of the 6 tents on this 14 day trip that did not ever get any dampness in through the floor (some got a LOT of water in through their floors).
On a couple of nights, the Goondie accumulated a substantial amount of condensation. However, there was one night in which I was very impressed with its ventillation performance. Keep in mind here that we were camped next to a raging spraying river, in a rainforest, where it had recently been raining, and during the day, my pack, including my tent, which was not in a dry sack on this particular day, was upside down under water for about 5 minutes while my raft was wrapped around a log (or was it while upside down caught in a stopper - I can't remember). So the tent was pretty sopping wet when I set it up, inside and out. But in the morning, it was quite dry. Certainly a lot drier than when I went to bed. So I was happy with that.
I experienced several rainy days on this SW Tas rafting trip, including
the storm which apparently brought a premature end to Tasmania's leatherwood honey season (and which added a lot of volume to the water in the river). The tent handled the rain very well. With the fly and tent doors both fully open, there was an occasional drip that did get into the tent, but for the most part the fly overhung the door just enough to prevent the rain getting in. Some certainly did get onto the inner adjacent to the door, but that fabric is reasonably water resistant, and was not a problem. I think that it would only take a very slight breeze in the wrong direction for rain to enter the tent while both doors were open, so you do need to be sure that you have it set up with the fly door facing down wind.
I can't comment on wind performance or snow performance still as we got no snow, and virtually no wind (being in deep, steep gorges most of the time). In fact I only used the two compulsory fly pegs most of the time, except when pitched in some odd places.
Oh yes, I sure pitched in some odd places. On a few occasions I was able to pitch this tent when the rest of the group had to resort to tarps and sleeping under rafts, because their tents would not fit in. But really, I think that's probably the case for most small one man tents - the rest of the group all had larger tents.
I'm now very firmly attached to the Goondie, and it would take an awful lot of persuasion to convince me to replace it with anything else. Would I buy another one if it got destroyed or stolen? Definitely. I don't even have to stop and think about that one. Is it perfect. No, I would still prefer integral pitch, but it's better than any other light weight one person tent for my needs that I've had any close encounters with (which is not many, by the way).