Page 1 of 1

Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Tue 13 Sep, 2011 5:52 pm
by Toohp
Hi , I'm trying to find a new Jacket that fits this description ? :D

100 % Fully waterproof
extremely lightweight under 500 grams even under 300 grams would be better , packs' very small .
Hood that fold's away into the collar or zip's away ( better )
Seam sealed
Event material would be great but something else as long as it's 100 % waterproof .
Under $300

I like the Montane Air but over my budget I'm afraid :( AND the Mac Pac too
My local shop suggest s Outdoor Research , what about Rab or Patagonia ? Any others I should consider ?
Am I asking too much ? :D

Toohp

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Tue 13 Sep, 2011 6:26 pm
by Marwood
Golite Kenai. Meets your criteria except for the fold away hood.

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Tue 13 Sep, 2011 10:07 pm
by Dale

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Wed 14 Sep, 2011 8:32 am
by blacksheep
Image
http://www.macpac.com.au/shop/en_au/gea ... verse.html
Toohp wrote:Hi , I'm trying to find a new Jacket that fits this description ? :D

100 % Fully waterproof

YEP
Toohp wrote:extremely lightweight under 500 grams even under 300 grams would be better , packs' very small .

Well, 370gms, but the extra zip in collar and tougher fabric accounts for that..

Toohp wrote:Hood that fold's away into the collar or zip's away ( better )

zips away.
Toohp wrote:Seam sealed
Event material would be great but something else as long as it's 100 % waterproof .

check and check...
Toohp wrote:Under $300

happy to look at a Bushwalk.com mates rates deal ;)

Toohp wrote:I like the Montane Air but over my budget I'm afraid :( AND the Mac Pac too
My local shop suggest s Outdoor Research , what about Rab or Patagonia ? Any others I should consider ?
Am I asking too much ? :D

Toohp

Well,no. I've sold the traverse jacket for $299.95 on a special before, so if that's the way you decide I can do it again. Let me know.
cheers,
Cam

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Wed 14 Sep, 2011 10:01 am
by Maelgwn
I have the traverse that Blacksheep recommends and have been happy with it. Can't remember what I paid, probably $300 or $330 on 'sale'.

Had it about 6 months and it has seen a few decent rainfalls and it has kept me dry. I haven't had it in a whole day of rain (tasmania style) yet but I can't imagine there being a problem. I like the long sleeves, lightweight and small pack size. Has the features you need and none you don't (except I may never pack the hood away).

DWR seems to be wearing off pretty quickly but no surprises there, will wash and re-proof soon.

Integral Designs looks good as well, but macpac is tempting as it is easy to see in the flesh and try before buying.

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Wed 14 Sep, 2011 12:26 pm
by Capt DropBear
I second the Macpac Traverse - very happy with it's performance, weight, price ($330 at the time), features (all you need, none you don't).
Some user reviews here:
viewtopic.php?f=15&t=5406

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Fri 16 Sep, 2011 1:39 pm
by Tas01
dont think you will get one for under $300 unless on sale. But im reading good things about Polartec NeoShell. Something to think about anyways.
Westcomb Apoc jacket
Marmot Zion Jacket $375 US..

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Sun 18 Sep, 2011 9:57 pm
by dannnnn
i am also looking for a new rain shell and have very similar requirements to the original poster...

..except i also want a jacket that is long enough to cover my backside. 95% of the jackets i've seen in stores are "hipster" cut... doesn't work very well in real life!!

Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Sun 18 Sep, 2011 10:07 pm
by Maelgwn
Try them on. Mine covers my backside just fine, not thighs as some people prefer though.

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Sun 18 Sep, 2011 11:23 pm
by mattmacman
My suggestion Outdoor Research Helium (if you dont go for macpac), mainpeak has it for $117.
Pros
-Lightweight 193 Grams Average
-Fully waterproof (NOTE eVent wets out!)
-Nice hood

Cons
-Not as durable
-Less pockets (who cares!)
-Not as breathable

Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Mon 19 Sep, 2011 7:13 am
by Maelgwn
mattmacman wrote:My suggestion Outdoor Research Helium (if you dont go for macpac), mainpeak has it for $117.
Pros
-Lightweight 193 Grams Average
-Fully waterproof (NOTE eVent wets out!)
-Nice hood

Cons
-Not as durable
-Less pockets (who cares!)
-Not as breathable


What makes you say event wets out?

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Mon 19 Sep, 2011 10:32 am
by mattmacman
Haven't tested it myself however when i was looking at buying a prophet XPD i posted a topic about jackets and i had quite a few people saying that occured, especially if you get dirt in it. However that is the Prophet XPD so you may achieve different results. Just wanted to make you aware about the problem. Also on a side note lately Macpac gear seems to be of 'lesser quality' i am a Macpac fan i simply observed that the sewing on jackets and workmanship seems to have slipped (at least on clothing), the first prophet i looked at had a broken pitzip because there was material over the zip or something =D Just check the jacket out, im sure anything macpac should still stand the test of time, perhaps i should speak to Blacksheep. Also lastly other brands are coming uut with other materials aswell such as Dry Q and the Stoic Vapourshell.

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Mon 19 Sep, 2011 2:36 pm
by blacksheep
i'm always interested in opinins about quality- feel free to e-mail me/ PM me / whatever with specifics or opinions. It is of the utmost importance to macpac.
also, not sure you'll see a heck of a lot of difference between eVent and DryQ ;)

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Mon 19 Sep, 2011 5:13 pm
by mattmacman
blacksheep wrote:i'm always interested in opinins about quality- feel free to e-mail me/ PM me / whatever with specifics or opinions. It is of the utmost importance to macpac.
also, not sure you'll see a heck of a lot of difference between eVent and DryQ ;)

Thanks for the reply Blacksheep, i appreciate you're acknowledgment rather than just brushing the claim aside, i still love macpac and their gear and im sure it will last years. As for the difference between DryQ and eVent the one thing i noticed was DryQ has a 'guaranteed to keep you dry' claim, as for breathability im sure there will be little or no difference either way between the two. I still prefer the macpac jacket as i love the hood (BEST FEATURE) as it is soo well designed and the thought to as where the reinforcements are etc, it just reflects the quality of macpac. Cheers Blacksheep!

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Mon 19 Sep, 2011 6:19 pm
by Maelgwn
mattmacman wrote:Haven't tested it myself however when i was looking at buying a prophet XPD i posted a topic about jackets and i had quite a few people saying that occured, especially if you get dirt in it. However that is the Prophet XPD so you may achieve different results. Just wanted to make you aware about the problem.


Aah, that is the nature of the DWR treatment and face fabrics involved and can occur with any waterproof/breathable fabric (gore, event, hyrdonaut, blah blah blah). It is not specific to event and will occur in all wp/b fabrics with time. Macpac seems to be getting a bad rap for this occurring quickly on these forums, time will tell if it justified or not.

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Mon 19 Sep, 2011 8:17 pm
by Toohp
mattmacman wrote:My suggestion Outdoor Research Helium (if you dont go for macpac), mainpeak has it for $117.
Pros
-Lightweight 193 Grams Average
-Fully waterproof (NOTE eVent wets out!)
-Nice hood

Cons
-Not as durable
-Less pockets (who cares!)
-Not as breathable


Wow that's a good price $ my local outdoor shop recomended that one & they wanted $220 .

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Mon 19 Sep, 2011 8:57 pm
by mattmacman
You can get them for as cheap as $81 AUS from america however they have limited sizes as they are very popular!

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Fri 30 Sep, 2011 4:10 pm
by Toohp
So I finally got a jacket , :D the Goodawana Kanyaka , a tad heavier than I wanted( 400 grams) but ticks nearly all the boxes for what I want especially for the $ , Anaconda has a sale on starting today reduced from $189 to $100 . I loved the Outdoor research helium but the hood dosn't pack away .

http://www.gondwanaoutdoor.com.au/index ... D=24440947

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Sat 01 Oct, 2011 4:28 pm
by Stibb
Toohp wrote:Am I asking too much ? :D

Apparently not. I just ordered a Columbia Peak 2 Peak with the new-ish omni-dry membrane and 450g from Amazon for $175

http://www.amazon.com/Columbia-Mens-Jacket-Compass-Medium/dp/B004I5MW0O/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1317450032&sr=8-1

I wish it was for me but at least my husband is excited about it. The price is great and hopefully it will be a good jacket :)

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Sat 15 Oct, 2011 1:01 pm
by wayno
the traverse has no pit zips or vented pockets in it., so if you're walking in warm weather you stand to swelter in it, i've overloaded event coats with sweat in heavy rain the traverse doesnt have external storm flap which can allow water in through the front zip in storm conditions.

look on somewhere like gearbuyer.com to see what deals you can get. might need to use a mail forewarding comapny for some brands.

i got the columbia omni dry peak 2 peak jacket on special for $200 in the states online, it sells for $400 in oz, reviews say its one of the most breathable fabrics out.
again this one has no external front storm flap it has a waterproof zipper and an insternal storm flap.. 440gms for a large

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Sat 15 Oct, 2011 1:05 pm
by Maelgwn
wayno wrote:the traverse has no pit zips or vented pockets in it., so if you're walking in warm weather you stand to swelter in it, i've overloaded event coats with sweat in heavy rain the traverse doesnt have external storm flap which can allow water in through the front zip in storm conditions.

look on somewhere like gearbuyer.com to see what deals you can get. might need to use a mail forewarding comapny for some brands.

i got the columbia omni dry peak 2 peak jacket on special for $200 in the states online, it sells for $400 in oz, reviews say its one of the most breathable fabrics out.
again this one has no external front storm flap it has a waterproof zipper and an insternal storm flap.. 440gms for a large


Traverse has waterproof zip and internal storm flap also.

There is a point in warm rain where you can overload any jacket with sweat. If it is that warm there is an argument for not wearing a jacket, using an umbrella or a poncho ...

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Sat 15 Oct, 2011 1:07 pm
by wayno
i have a traverse, the zip might claim to be waterproof but water does get in through it in storms

Re: Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Wed 26 Oct, 2011 4:28 pm
by glg520
I'm also looking for a new jacket like that , but in low price.


blacksheep wrote:Image
http://www.macpac.com.au/shop/en_au/gea ... verse.html
Toohp wrote:Hi , I'm trying to find a new Jacket that fits this description ? :D

100 % Fully waterproof

YEP
Toohp wrote:extremely lightweight under 500 grams even under 300 grams would be better , packs' very small .

Well, 370gms, but the extra zip in collar and tougher fabric accounts for that..

Toohp wrote:Hood that fold's away into the collar or zip's away ( better )

zips away.
Toohp wrote:Seam sealed
Event material would be great but something else as long as it's 100 % waterproof .

check and check...
Toohp wrote:Under $300

happy to look at a Bushwalk.com mates rates deal ;)

Toohp wrote:I like the Montane Air but over my budget I'm afraid :( AND the Mac Pac too
My local shop suggest s Outdoor Research , what about Rab or Patagonia ? Any others I should consider ?
Am I asking too much ? :D

Toohp

Well,no. I've sold the traverse jacket for $299.95 on a special before, so if that's the way you decide I can do it again. Let me know.
cheers,
Cam

Looking for a new Jacket

PostPosted: Wed 26 Oct, 2011 6:06 pm
by Maelgwn
glg520 wrote:I'm also looking for a new jacket like that , but in low price.


blacksheep wrote:Image
http://www.macpac.com.au/shop/en_au/gea ... verse.html
Toohp wrote:Hi , I'm trying to find a new Jacket that fits this description ? :D

100 % Fully waterproof

YEP
Toohp wrote:extremely lightweight under 500 grams even under 300 grams would be better , packs' very small .

Well, 370gms, but the extra zip in collar and tougher fabric accounts for that..

Toohp wrote:Hood that fold's away into the collar or zip's away ( better )

zips away.
Toohp wrote:Seam sealed
Event material would be great but something else as long as it's 100 % waterproof .

check and check...
Toohp wrote:Under $300

happy to look at a Bushwalk.com mates rates deal ;)

Toohp wrote:I like the Montane Air but over my budget I'm afraid :( AND the Mac Pac too
My local shop suggest s Outdoor Research , what about Rab or Patagonia ? Any others I should consider ?
Am I asking too much ? :D

Toohp

Well,no. I've sold the traverse jacket for $299.95 on a special before, so if that's the way you decide I can do it again. Let me know.
cheers,
Cam


Hey mate. What is your intended use? What features do you want?

Remember the big three of gear ( price vs weight vs quality)